Shelley Hennig Embraces the Chaos in Best Pancakes in the County

There are some actors who carefully map out every career move, sticking to familiar genres and comfortable territory. Then there is Shelley Hennig, who seems far more interested in one simple question: Is it fun? That mindset is exactly what led her to Ken Sanzel's action-thriller Best Pancakes in the County, where she stars alongside Nicolas Cage and Justin Long in a story packed with secrets, shifting loyalties, and explosive confrontations inside a small-town diner.

During a recent conversation, what stood out most was just how much Hennig genuinely enjoys the unpredictability of her work. While audiences may know her best from horror favorites like Unfriended and Ouija, she has never been interested in limiting herself to a single genre. In fact, when asked what drew her to Best Pancakes in the County, her answer was refreshingly simple.

"I don't discriminate," Hennig explained. "Fun is a huge... it's a privilege to read a script and be like, 'Wow, this looks fun.'" That sense of enthusiasm was strengthened by the opportunity to work alongside Cage and Long, as well as reunite with producers she had collaborated with before. She loves projects that allow her to explore different sides of a character, and Best Pancakes in the County offered exactly that.

In the film, Hennig plays Dolly, a diner waitress who appears ordinary on the surface but is hiding far more than she initially lets on. As the night unfolds, the audience learns that Dolly is far more capable and dangerous than anyone expects. Rather than playing her as someone overwhelmed by the escalating chaos around her, Hennig viewed the character through a unique lens.

"Dolly's reality is that she's used to life and death situations," Hennig said. For Dolly, remembering breakfast orders is far less important than surviving what is rapidly becoming a deadly standoff. That contrast between routine diner life and escalating violence became one of the aspects of the character Hennig enjoyed most. She described Dolly as someone constantly fighting to maintain a cover identity while suppressing parts of herself that want to emerge.

The role also pushed Hennig into action territory in ways audiences may not expect. The actress spent considerable time working on the film's tactical elements, learning weapon handling and developing a distinct style for Dolly's combat scenes. While she has experience with physical performances, she admitted some aspects of the production presented new challenges, particularly the knife work that became part of Dolly's arsenal. Fortunately, a talented stunt team helped bring those moments to life while ensuring the character's unique personality was reflected in every action sequence.

One of the film's greatest strengths is its contained setting. Nearly the entire story unfolds over the course of a single night inside a diner that becomes the center of a deadly confrontation involving criminals, rogue federal agents, and competing agendas. The diner itself almost becomes a character in the film. Hennig spent much of the shoot in that location and spoke fondly about the environment created by the production team, explaining that the set quickly became familiar while still offering new corners to explore, mirroring Dolly's own experience throughout the story.

Of course, it's impossible to talk about Best Pancakes in the County without mentioning Cage. Few actors bring the level of anticipation and unpredictability that he does. Hennig laughed while recalling how Cage kept his appearance under wraps until filming began.

"We didn't know what that was going to look like," she said of his costume, hair, and makeup choices. "And I was like, 'Oh my God, here we go. I love it.'" Yet the biggest surprise for Hennig wasn't some larger-than-life eccentricity. Instead, she described Cage as sincere, approachable, and eager to share the inspirations behind his creative choices. One particularly memorable moment came when Cage improvised multiple takes using Dolly's name, creating an inside joke that continued among the crew long after filming wrapped. It's the kind of spontaneous creativity that has helped make Cage one of the most fascinating performers working today.

Ironically, despite being beloved by horror fans, Hennig isn't exactly the horror fanatic many might expect. That realization led our conversation down an entertaining path. While discussing her past work in genre favorites like Unfriended and Ouija, Hennig admitted that she doesn't particularly enjoy watching horror movies herself. The revelation felt almost impossible to believe considering how frequently audiences associate her with the genre, but it speaks to something that became increasingly clear throughout the interview: Hennig doesn't choose projects because they fit a label. She chooses them because she sees something exciting in the material.

That openness has allowed her career to continually evolve. Although she acknowledged that her horror experience helped build the foundation for future performances, she sees every project as part of a larger learning process. Looking at Dolly, Hennig recognized the difference between the younger characters she portrayed earlier in her career and the more experienced, battle-tested woman at the center of Best Pancakes in the County. Reflecting on her journey, she noted that "everything we've all done is setting you up for the next thing as long as your eyes are open," a philosophy that clearly guides her approach to new opportunities.

What ultimately makes Best Pancakes in the County stand out isn't just the action, mystery, or tension. According to Hennig, it's the humor. The cast and filmmakers were committed to balancing danger with absurdity, creating a film that can make audiences laugh one moment and grip their armrests the next. Hennig revealed that director Ken Sanzel was drawn to her comedy work when considering her for the role, a reminder that her talents extend far beyond the horror projects many fans know best.

As for what she hopes audiences take away from the experience, Hennig's answer perfectly captures the spirit of the movie.

"I want them to feel chaos and fun," she said. She praised the script's originality and described it as one of those rare projects where everything was already on the page. Combined with a cast led by Cage and Long, she believes audiences are in for something genuinely unique.

After spending time speaking with Hennig, it's easy to understand why she was drawn to Best Pancakes in the County. Whether she's navigating horror, comedy, action, or something impossible to categorize, she approaches every project with curiosity and enthusiasm. That's particularly exciting here because Best Pancakes in the County feels like another step forward, giving her the opportunity to showcase different skills while still delivering the wit and charisma audiences have come to expect.

And if our conversation proved anything, it's that while horror may be the genre most associated with Shelley Hennig, she's more interested in chasing good stories than staying in any one lane. If those stories happen to involve secretive waitresses, rogue agents, Nicolas Cage improvisations, and the best pancakes in the county, all the better.

Jessie Hobson